Author: Sorting Last Post on Top Message:
MEMEME75 Posts: 658
4/27/12 9:15 A

If I am exercising in the morning, I drink half a bottle of slim-fast. It gives me some carbs/protein for a little boost. If I am exercising after work, then I don't bother with a snack or meal. I wait until after the workout.

Edited by: MEMEME75 at: 4/27/2012 (13:01)
TENNISX92 Posts: 71
4/27/12 9:11 A

I've heard that you should have a small snack to give yourself a bit of fuel to keep your body going, and so you don't run out of energy too quickly. You should eat something (with protein if possible) definitely within an hour of your workout. The protein is to help rebuilding muscles you tear.

After studying abroad and walking everywhere/starving without a meal plan for a month, I'm starting now at 144.
I don't have a scale in my room this month so I won't get to weigh in more than once a month when I'm home =\

October 12: 140
November 21: 136
December 14: 132
FISHFAN Posts: 245
4/27/12 8:47 A

Depends, I eat when I'm hungry but I don't like to be too full if I'm going to workout.

DRAGONCHILDE SparkPoints: (58,536)
Fitness Minutes: (14,252)
Posts: 9,692
4/27/12 8:16 A

You don't burn more (or less) eating on either a full OR empty stomach. There's a common myth that if you work out first thing in the morning, you'll burn more fat; there's no evidence of this at all. It's all about your personal comfort; now, there IS something to the idea of eating before; if you don't eat, you may get a blood sugar drop... eating beforehand can prevent that dip, if you're sensitive to such changes.

Writer, mother, wife, and breadwinner. I love to run, but running doesn't love me, so I'm switching to my low-impact bike.

I'm not pregnant, just fat: My blog.
CROWLEY123 SparkPoints: (34,393)
Fitness Minutes: (29,278)
Posts: 1,518
4/27/12 7:26 A

I'm with BubbleJ - I eat after because it feels better, I get a better workout, and I don't think my food settles well if I eat before.

Do whatever works best for you.

~ ~ Terri ~ ~

My goal is to have more fitness minutes than SparkPoints!
I strive to be a body in motion, each and every day.
MPLANE37 SparkPoints: (65,711)
Fitness Minutes: (35,117)
Posts: 2,167
4/27/12 6:58 A

It is true that during the exercise you don't burn the food that you have eaten just before the exercise. You use already available energy sources, both various forms of glucose and fatty acids.

I used to exercise before eating any food, and later have some snack. But it was almost always difficult to stop snacking after a strenuous workout. So recently I started to exercise preferably half an hour to 45 min. of eating lunch.

Within 45 min. of starting a meal, the digestion is not over. So when you start exercising, after about 10-15 minutes, the blood is drawn to muscles working strenuously, and not much blood is left for the digestive system. So digestion slows down. When I am done working out, in a short while blood is now drawn to the digestive system, and the digestion continues.

The end result is that I don't feel hungry after the workout.


It may not work for everyone, though. It seems to work fine with me (well, I get occasional burps but nothing more).

``Don't break the chain." -Jerry Seinfeld
``Moments of silence are part of the music." -Anonymous
BUBBLEJ1 Posts: 2,981
4/27/12 1:58 A

Do what works for you. I eat after because otherwise I feel sick while doing cardio. I have to have a good 3-4 hours between a meal and exercise, with a small snack about 30 minutes before. You might be different! Try both and see what happens


There are no shortcuts. No magic bullets. No secret spells. What works is hard work, dedication, and a daily dose of chocolate.
UNIDENT Posts: 33,498
4/27/12 1:55 A

Despite claims like PAGANCENTAUR's, no you do not get energy from foods you've just eaten. Digesting food and converting it to energy for your muscles takes hours.

Some people find that they are more comfortable not working out on an empty stomach - or that they ARE more comfortable working out on an empty stomach!

No, you're absolutely right in your own approach - it doesn't make a lick of difference, it's purely personal preference, and just generally being active and eating healthy is the only real key.

Deb, in New Zealand
4/27/12 12:48 A

i do my cardio within 30 minutes of eating so i will have the energy from the food to make it thru my workout

"The most successful people are the ones with a modest amount of talent and a huge amount of discipline."

"It's okay to put yourself first. 'Selfish' isn't a dirty word. If we were all selfish, it would mean we would take care of ourselves and be able to give back to our loved ones." --Jillian Michaels

"There is no finish line, you have to live this way for the rest of your life!" --Bob Harper
KAPELAKIN Posts: 1,984
4/27/12 12:08 A

I don't think it really matters. Personally,. I like to have a small snack before a run, then have my main meal afterwards. If you're doing a major workout that lasts over an hour, it's more important to make sure your muscles have adequate fuel, but for 30 minutes of exercise, it's really a matter of preference. You're right that you won't be burning off the calories you just consumed. You're burning glycogen stored in your muscles during a 30 minute workout. The calories in your meal will go towards replenishing those glycogen stores.

Voluntary Discomfort is the secret cornerstone of strength. We build our whole lives around increasing comfort and avoiding discomfort, and yet by doing so we are drinking a can of Weakness Tonic with every morning’s breakfast. ~Mr. Money Mustache
5K PR: 23:40
10K PR: 48:57
HM PR: 1:59:37
30K: 2:57:44
AMANADA759 Posts: 9
4/26/12 11:44 P

Does it really matter when you exercise? I understand not exercising right after a big meal, but unless I can tell that a few minutes on the stationary bike is going to give me cramps does it really make a difference? I've read before that if you exercise after eating you're only burning the calories you just consumed-which honestly leaves me confused how I'm burning calories that are still in my stomach and haven't even been processed into my body yet. Even if that is true would it matter? Wouldn't that be like taking some off the top and leaving some on the bottom? You'd still end up with the same amount.

I'm just starting to get back into a cardio routine and so far I'm only a week in. I don't pay attention to what time of day I get my exercise in, as long as I make sure I get at least 20-25 minutes (for now). There are all kinds of "rules" and "tips" all over the place of when to exercise, the miracle foods and the foods to avoid at all costs, when to eat those foods, thermogenics, etc. I'm mostly just concerned with trying to eat healthy and create a calorie deficit through that and exercise to lose weight. Is it really more difficult than that?

Page: 1 of (1)  

Other Fitness and Exercise Topics:

Topics: Last Post:
long drive, any suggestions 10/28/2014 6:38:52 AM
Extremely low muscle mass 10/27/2014 1:53:26 PM
Advice For Sedentary People 8/13/2014 8:40:20 PM
Should I track my break walks? 8/21/2014 10:27:00 PM
Do physiotherapy exercises count.. 1/31/2015 8:37:09 AM