Advertisement -- Learn more about ads on this site.

Member Comments for the Article:

4 Signs It's Time to Step Off the Scale

Does Weight Weigh Heavily on Your Mind?

93 Comments







RENATARUNS

6/16/2014 9:59:22 AM

RENATARUNS's SparkPage
I very much disagree on weighing only weekly, unless someone has a truly negative "relationship" with it as described in this article. Knowledge is power. How often do I see people on the forums panicking because they "haven't lost weight in two weeks", when for all they know they actually did, just keep gaining meaningless water weight the day before weigh-in because that's their one day a week to have pizza? When you weigh daily, the trends are so much easier to see, and any temporary panic over a gain is almost always dispelled within days when the scale goes down a bunch all at once. When you weigh only weekly, you are unlikely to have any true idea of what's going on, potentially for weeks at a time.

IMO if scale watching is too stressful for a person, they should weigh not weekly, but only once a *month* (for a woman, at the same point in her menstrual cycle. I've seen one week after onset of her period suggested, and that makes sense to me). Monthly is usually enough time for those meaningless fluctuations to even out, such that even if you get the worst possible combination of water weights from one month to the next, you'll likely still see some loss (if you had any). Weekly is the worst of both worlds.

Finally -- for maintenance, I believe that frequent weighing is vital. Most successful maintainers do it, and closer to daily than to weekly. There's no better way to prevent a one pound gain from turning into a five pound gain from turning into "oh I give up".

DUGDIXIE1

6/15/2014 6:40:53 PM

DUGDIXIE1's SparkPage
Your right. You sometimes have to see other changes that are taking place like your measurements and the way you are thinking. My attitude has got a lot better since I don't stress over weighing. That is just one of the tools that we use for progress.

BROOKLYN_BORN

6/15/2014 4:50:37 PM

BROOKLYN_BORN's SparkPage
Ignoring the scale is how I gained the weight in the first place, I won't make that mistake again. I credit my 4+ years of maintenance to my daily morning weigh in. It doesn't affect my mood. It keeps me honest.

PITTER6

6/15/2014 4:04:53 PM

PITTER6's SparkPage
A few months ago, I had to ditch the scales. They were driving me crazy. I started counting my points. that showed that I was drinking the water, tracking my food and reading the articles. I set a goal of 3000 points a month. I am into my 3rd month and doing fine. Have I lost weight. I don't know! It's okay. I feel good and I am staying on the journey to a healthy lifestyle, not on a diet.

XBIBBLESX

6/15/2014 12:25:38 PM

XBIBBLESX's SparkPage
Now that I'm in maintenance for the most part, I weigh myself at least once a week because it can get away from you if you're not vigilant.

LAURADIONJONES

6/15/2014 9:26:51 AM

Use your daily morning weight as MOTIVATION, nothing else. Motivation to do your daily cardio and not eat withe starch and sugar carb crap - nothing else matters in weight loss. Get 'er done.

LAURADIONJONES

6/15/2014 9:20:55 AM

Use your daily morning weight as MOTIVATION, nothing else. Motivation to do your daily cardio and not eat withe starch and sugar carb crap - nothing else matters in weight loss. Get 'er done.

BUCS1221

4/29/2014 7:38:15 PM

BUCS1221's SparkPage
Thank you this article really help me out and I have been weighting myself every other day and I notice it would go up or down and it did affect my moods. Now I am going to do it every 2 weeks weighing in. I am trying to get to the 10 lb mark I only have 2 more lbs to go and I have been stepping on the scale a lot often so I am going to leave it alone now. although I have heart problems and they say that fluid will make u gain weight fast so sometimes I wonder if that is the case when scales goes up. Thanks again
Tammy

FFTAZ71

3/22/2014 12:58:16 PM

FFTAZ71's SparkPage
I weigh myself daily, but I use that number more as a confirmation that Im doing ok. I do allow for some fluctuations but if the trend is going downward for the most part or staying close to the same, I know I am doing ok. If I see it creeping up continually, I know that I have to change something. The scale just gives me a number that I use as one more tool in my box. I weigh myself, step off and either I keep doing what Im doing or I reflect on whether or not Im doing everything I should be. Surprisingly, the scale is a motivator for me...to keep going when Im doing great and to keep trying when I have no so great weeks. Its definitely not my be all and end all though...

ITSUP2MARIA

10/20/2013 2:22:51 PM

ITSUP2MARIA's SparkPage
Much wisdom in this posting. Thanks the "dose of reality"

MCCC75

10/20/2013 11:27:34 AM

MCCC75's SparkPage
I need to really be mindful of this as I let the scale have way too much control over my day.....I am going to try and only weigh in once a week....will have to have daughter hide the scale for me. I am hoping that will help me with this long journey back to health!

GLSGIRL64

9/5/2013 7:17:23 AM

GLSGIRL64's SparkPage
This speaks so perfectly to my mind set this morning! I felt that I worked so hard these past few days, but the scale gave me nothing in return. Have I been feeling better? Yes!
Have I been making better choices? Yes! Have I been more physically active? Yes! So why can't I accept these as successes and give myself a pat on the back?

BUB001

8/4/2013 1:24:28 AM

BUB001's SparkPage
Because I have heart health issues, my cardiologist advised me to weigh myself several times daily to ensure that I'm not retaining fluids. I only track my weight in full pounds, and enter in my home journal full pounds based on same-time every morning weigh-in. I do occasionally enter my weight online even if there is no loss. However, I do not let what I weigh affect my drive to become healthier.

EDNASHUKIS

4/9/2013 11:04:40 AM

EDNASHUKIS's SparkPage
This is me too, I am afraid if I don't weigh everyday I will gain a whole bunch of weight and not know it, but that is my OCD... I am going to try and weigh only once a week from now on. I will probably have anxiety until next week. tomarrow is the end of wk 1 for me and I will use today's weight. At least I finally lost something. Edna

OPERATIONXMAS

4/2/2013 9:56:59 PM

OPERATIONXMAS's SparkPage
Honestly, this is me. I put so much importance on the results of the scale that I forgot that I did eat well, drink water and exercised. Ignoring all that only because a number of the scale doesn't move isn't the way to go. This leads to me giving up and that is bad. This time I will not measure my success by the scale and just work hard!

Comment Pages (7 total)
[1]

Leave a comment


  Log in to leave a comment.