SparkPeople advertisers help keep the site free! Learn more
Member Comments for the Article:
What Causes Heart Disease?
Are You At Risk for Heart Disease?
3/14/2013 11:15:53 AM
My two cents worth!? These are the general, widely accepted risk factors and lifestyle chioces that are linked to heart disease and heart attack. There are always exceptions and "atypical" bodies when it comes to any physical problem! As a result, we need to do our best to pay attetnion to our bodies and be very persistent when dealing with the medical profession, as well as paying attetnion to our tendancies to ignore symptoms or put off seeking answers. I am 49 with personal and family HISTORY of high blood pressure, high cholestrol, and early onset heart disease. I first noticed personal SYMPTOMS (angina during exercise) in my early 40's which was swept under the rug by an ignorant cardiologist who gave me a stress test and pronounced me to be "fine" . In the past nine months I've had to push to get the correct testing and finally had an angiogram two weeks ago resulting in angioplasty and stent placement for an 80% blockage on a major artery in my heart. Having a diagnosis of Coraonary Heart Disease is not ideal for me but actually having a diagnosis and a REAL cardiologist after 7 years is a relief! I wish I'd been more persistant sooner!!
1/31/2013 1:46:57 PM
Read Dr. William Davis's book "Wheat Belly"!!!! It changed my life. I'm sad that my dear husband has been misled by articles like this. He has had a heart attack in the past and now stents just recently. Obviously, he and the rest of America who follow the AHA recommendations are still getting sick. Maybe, something needs to change!! I follow a grain-free, sugar free diet, high fat diet and I feel great. My cholesterol and trig values are low and my HDL is sky high. Why are these so called heart health specialists misleading us????
9/17/2012 3:01:09 AM
All I want to say is I am glad there are others who dont agree with the information in this article. I have watched Fat Head, which is a great documentary. I highly recommend it to others who want to know more about why this information is incorrect. I am on a high fat, low carb diet, exercise 6 days per week and my health has improved dramatically. I have blood tests to support my claims, plus thousands of others who have achieved the same results. You'll find there are a lot of scientific studies to back this up if you look into it & not just one.
3/25/2012 8:38:48 PM
I am normal weight, exercise regularly, have low BP, great cholesterol numbers, eat a healthy and balanced diet, no family history of heart disease, and have an hourglass rather than an apple shape. At age 59 I had a heart attack! A tiny piece of plaque broke away from a blood vessel in my heart and caused a blockage. My cardiologist said I had better odds of being the single winner of the $135 million lottery that weekend than of having that heart attack! My GP was stunned. Luckily, I recognized the symptoms--different in women than men, so educate yourselves ladies--called 911 immediately, and was in the OR having two stents put in within 90 minutes of the onset. Completely recovered now with no damage, though I struggled with depression and anxiety for about 9 months afterwards. Looking back, the only risk factor that my cardiologist and GP could come up with was stress from a combination of factors in my life. I have since added yoga and Tai Chi Chih to my exercise routine. I'm sure that the reason I regained my health so quickly is that I took care of myself to begin with and knew the symptoms of a heart attack in women. Next time I defy any odds I hope I end up with the $135 mil!
As a heart patient, and editor of a monthly newsletter for an organization of heart patients, I believe this is a good unbiased overview of current knowledge of the risk factors for coronary heart disease (the most prevalent kind of heart disease).
It isn't perfect. I like the comment by JENG829 about the uncertain role of saturated fat. But while I congratulate CHRIS3847 on the health of his long lived grandfather, a study with one subject proves nothing. I had low risk and a double bypass at 65. We know some statistical risk factors, but not clear and definite causes.
My main complaint is not with the article itself but with its headlines. The title on the web page is "What Causes Heart Disease?" but the article lists risk factors, not causes. An email today linked to it with the heading "Calculate your heart attack risk" but while the article lists risk factors you can't calculate anything from it. But as a list of risk factors, I like it.
Recent analysis of studies has shown that saturated fat is not clearly linked to heart disease, so I wish these types of articles would be updated with that information.
The only studies I've seen that showed red meat to be correlated with disease combine red meats & processed meats, which are two very different things. Processed meats often contain fillers & preservatives which are known carcinogens. Red meat is just, well, meat. Natural. If there are updated studies, I'd like to see those referenced instead ofthe same old substandard studies.
This frustrates me because we have been told these "guidelines" for years, and many people I have known followed the guidelines, getting sicker and fatter in the process. There has to be something other than this "one size fits all" low-fat high-starch approach.
Here we go again a vegan is going to tell us all how to live - well you know what my Grandpa ate RED MEAT his ENTIRE live and lived to be 98 and NEVER had heart disease!!! If I were you I wouldn't be quoting from the huffington post what a bunch of BS that thing spouts.
7/28/2011 11:35:55 AM
Cardiologist Dr. Davis of the old heartscanblog.blogspot.com now trackyourplaque believes wheat/gluten to be a culprit, too. He doesn't believe in whole grains ... can't help but appreciate his message knowing what I know, so I share with you to make your own decision: http://bit.ly/oaKZJ2 .
SparkPeople, SparkCoach, SparkPages, SparkPoints, SparkTeams, SparkDiet, SparkAmerica, SparkRecipes, DailySpark, and other marks are trademarks of SparkPeople, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
SPARKPEOPLE is a registered trademark of SparkPeople, Inc. in the United States, European Union, Canada, and Australia. All rights reserved.