Member Comments for the Article:

Break Free from the Scale!

How to Stop the Scale from Determining Your Self-Worth

61 Comments



  • ALNKATHY
    Finally permission to put aside the scale, which Makes me anxious and filled with dread. I eat between 1200-1500 calories daily. I use fitness pal to monitor daily intake. My weight is pretty stable - 8/27/2014 7:56:21 PM
  • I get on my scale every morning. Obsessive? Probably. I like to see which way I am going daily instead of getting a shock at the end of 30 days then have to try to figure out what happened and when. I put away my scale for 30 days once. I didn't even get on the scale at the gym. I worked out at the gym, watched what I was eating. It was tough and disastrous! I gained weight!! I will continue to weigh every day. I only get excited with more than a 2 lbs loss, because I know weight fluctuates with workouts, time of day and water intake. - 7/17/2014 7:29:28 AM
  • It is only after I banished my scale to the closet and began concentrating on my health, rather than my weight, did I go down two sizes. For me, the weekly/daily weigh in was an exercise in humiliation and self-loathing. The scale isn't for everybody. It certainly isn't for me. If your emotional well-being is tied to the number on the scale, it is time to rethink using it. If it doesn't bother you, go ahead, keep using it. We are all very different in our relationship to the scale. Do what makes sense for you. Personally I am way too sensitive. I can't handle the emotional repercussions when the scale doesn't show the results I am expecting.It just makes me want to give up. - 7/16/2014 8:56:57 PM
  • OK, I know a number of people say you should not weigh yourself daily, but if I know that my weight fluctuates from day to day, it still seems better to know what it is and what the range is that it's fluctuating in. If you only weigh yourself once a week, how do you know where you are in your range at that moment? It seems like you could get a weight that is higher or lower than you should be tracking. Using a tape measure is great monthly but a lot can happen in that month that you would be better off knowing about before you've suddenly got an extra 5 pounds to deal with. - 7/16/2014 12:48:38 PM
  • GREENEYEDLADY54
    Wow! Obviously the scale is a very controversial subject for people. I am a scale person. I have watched it go up and up and up. I have decided I am going to participate in the Spark People program and lose the extra weight I need to lose. I need to lose a whole person...at least 100 pounds...125 would be awesome. I need help and I think I can find it here. It seems like there are always people on line talking and sharing ideas just like this one. I don't think I will weigh for a while. It is so depressing. - 5/3/2014 5:28:07 AM
  • DIETER27
    excellent article. well said......... - 4/4/2014 9:47:21 AM
  • I am with Healthy4HM. I do not ever want to lose the precious relationship I have with my scale:) I do use it in moderation though, never daily, always weekly. - 10/4/2013 8:28:58 PM
  • This scares the pants off of me... which probably means it's something I really need to consider.
    - 8/29/2013 5:26:26 PM
  • I used to weigh myself daily, then it went up to two times a day! I finally stopped and now I try for once a week. This last week I weighed myself twice onto of my weekly weigh in, so it's not easy to stop but I'm getting better. - 8/29/2013 4:56:30 PM
  • CAPPIE1277
    To those who think the scale keeps you accountable are probably the ones with the most scale obsession!! Weighing daily is not giving you a good accuracy at all! You do realize your weight can fluctuate several pounds in the course of a week. So if it shows you gained, what you eat less or exercise more... So not accurate at all!! - 8/29/2013 4:13:54 PM
  • People: spark is not hating on the scale. This to help people who are litterally obessed with weighingand place all their self-worth on those numbers that pop up on the scale. I used to wweigh myself probably 5-12 times a day and I HAD to break that habit because it was impeding my weight loss and hurting my mental health. After i broke my habit and learned to let that number go, i have been able to focus on what matters. I still weigh myself, but can now look at the numvers in the scale without a huge amount of anxiety behind them. If you dont feel that way about a scale, then you probably dont have a weighing obsession you need to break! Everyone just needs to calm down and realize not every piece of advice is written for them. - 8/22/2013 11:46:42 AM
  • I never step on a scale! I couldn't deal with the trauma of the numbers going up and down, seemingly erratically!

    Instead I very accurately log everything I eat, and my FitBit (which syncs to SP) accurately counts the calories I burn in a 24 hour period (even while I am asleep).

    With these logs in place, I use the SP Report called Daily Calorie Differential. SInce mid April, I have had a calorie deficit (burned more than I ate) for all but 6 days.

    Since mid-April, I have I have lost 13 pounds (divide the spreadsheet total by 3500 to get total pounds lost).

    This really works for me! I am getting smaller and smaller and my clothes are getting bigger and bigger!

    With no anxiety, dread, depression, etc. caused by the erratic numbers on the scale (which may be caused by water retention, etc.)

    Love my system! I works so well for me! I stay on track, and love the progress I am making with losing weight!

    - 7/12/2013 10:21:57 PM
  • Excellent article! - 7/12/2013 11:59:48 AM
  • I definitely agree with the folks who say the scale keeps them accountable. If I don't weigh myself once a day, I slip and gain a ton of weight. I will say that I am less obsessed than I used to be. I used to get on the scale about five times a day. I've also discovered that if I stall for a while, I can make adjustments to help me get things moving again. In fact, this happened recently. I was eating too little and exercising too much, and I was able to make adjustments to finally start losing again. It's a diagnostic tool, and I think if you use it as such, it's not a bad thing. - 7/12/2013 9:03:57 AM
  • I step on that scale every day. It helps me keep focused on my goals. If I don't step on it in the morning I tend to get sloppy with food choices during the day. It's just another tool to help with the journey, don't understand why SP thinks it is a bad thing. - 7/12/2013 8:25:16 AM

Comment Pages (5 total)
[1]

Leave a comment


  Log in to leave a comment.