Member Comments for the Article:

10 Ways to Stop Binge Eating in Its Tracks

How to Prevent a Binge and Regain Control

61 Comments



  • Please sparkpeople .... please stop the articles telling binge eaters how to eat sugar in controlled amounts. I love sparkpeople ... this website helped me lose 90 pounds. But this advice is dangerous and erroneous. Sugar and processed foods are addictive. I'm no purist. But it's one thing to have two or three cookies when I'm at a party (even that can make me vulnerable to a binge) and another thing to bring a carton of ice cream (or a package of cookies or bag of candy) into the house. I would eat it all by the next day! Does that make me not "strong"? Fine then, I'm weak. Weak and 90 pounds thinner!
    Would you tell a hardcore smoker who was trying to quit to just have a few cigarettes every day and to keep them around the house? Binge eating isn't just about behavior, it's about the substances. How many people do you know who binge on broccoli and apples???????? - 3/28/2016 12:10:16 AM
  • don't ask a binger to have a box of anything favorite around and eat just one - a - day.... It will never happen and is a setup for failure. - 3/26/2016 12:52:28 PM
  • "However, I think the goal would be to work towards enjoying a small serving of a trigger food whenever a craving strikes in order to avoid the inevitable binge that usually follows bouts of restriction. For some, allowing a small serving of a trigger food throughout the week can prevent binges".

    Hear, hear. However I miss one very important condition here: one must agree to how often per week one is going to indulge.
    In the BED treatment that I followed I was taught to plan in 2 to 3 treats per week, and 2-3 special meals per week. That worked fine. I feel that it is quite necessary though to agree beforehand HOW MANY treats you can have per week. If you've had your 3 treats, then just tell yourself you have the food you crave as soon as a new week starts - planned, as a treat, not as a moment of madness. - 3/26/2016 12:21:37 PM
  • Contrary to this and similar recommendations other places, I found that trying to eat small amounts of sweets often was a very bad idea. The fact that people overdo it on weekends after being "good" all week I believe is because of two things: they are not committed in general to moderate eating, and they have not been coached through the learning phase. I my sweet eating is almost exclusively on weekends, and now always in company. Exceptions a maximum of two days a month. Eating sweets every day while cutting down on them is very difficult for bingers. Nothing has been as valuable for me as having several days in a row every week (and sometimes much longer, after six years of practice) of not eating sugar, though I do use stevia in coffee and tea, and lightly in a few other foods. Another crucial part of my recovery was eating FULL meals at routine times (a one or two-hour window) and NOT snacking on weekdays, either which is how most slim, long-lived cultures have lived. My body has gotten very used to longer stretches and pulls out its reserves very well. Bottom line is bingeing is a HABIT, and habits can be changed. - 3/26/2016 11:34:09 AM
  • I have only recently discovered the source of my binge eating sessions. In high school, I thought skipping lunch would be an effective weight loss tool, so from years of that, my body seems to be conditioned to signal 'hungry' when I leave the office at the end of the day, the same way it was signaling hungry on the bus ride home every night. If I don't have a meal prepared or within a minute or two of nuking in the microwave, I will eat anything and everything until I've got something 'real' prepared to eat. I call it 'hoover mouth'. I literally am saying to myself 'you're not hungry, why are you doing this?' and still keep eating. I have been working hard the last few weeks to always do meal prep ahead of time to make sure there is something nutritious and filling at home that feels like a 'real meal'. - 1/13/2016 9:12:38 PM
  • Binge eating is a disorder for me. Thanks Sparkpeople for the article. The only solution for me is to not eat all the sweets that I love. I've also found that once I get them out of my system, the cravings stop. Now if I can never start back I'll be fine but unfortunately something calls me back even tho I'm not craving. It's a comfort situation I think. - 12/26/2015 3:46:34 PM
  • I keep reading comments about eating at night or binge eating. Both are very real. But I also read people writing in about " this is the same information that has been going around for years" that too is true. However as I became overweight 25 years ago, my doctor told me something I never forgot " to lose weight you have to take in less than you expend" That was 20 years ago. also told me that "binge eating is more about a behavioral/mental problem than a health issues" Maybe these items have been recycled because it is that simple for 95% of all people. Those pesky facts.... :-) Keep the fact coming folks - 12/7/2015 4:06:13 PM
  • I think we can all agree that no tip will work for everyone in every situation. I understand it is disappointing when we try tips and they don't work for us, but that can still be a positive thing: checking off something that doesn't work from the list and trying something else. And I agree with many commenters that this article does not address the binge eating disorder.

    I personally like the idea of using tiny forks, spoons, and bowls for the scheduled treat. When I have rich, chocolatey treats in a bowl, I use a tiny shrimp fork or a baby spoon... not the bulky plastic ones they sell now, but a delicate stainless steel spoon with a long, slender handle. This works for me. I can't say it will work for others. However, I have a mental-emotional-etc attachment to chocolate. I am not giving it up, so I found a way to make peace with my chocolate attachment. I value quality of life over longevity.

    The first tip is also helpful for me... putting my portion on my plate instead of eating from a container. - 12/7/2015 10:29:23 AM
  • This article has been here being recycled for years now. I wish they had some new things. - 12/7/2015 6:07:20 AM
  • I'm sorry, but people who say instead of eating a whole tub of ice cream, ( or bar of chocolate, or cake or whatever) have a little bit each day really don't get what the problem is. My partner is one of those who can have a load of sweets in the house and just eat one or two and then forget them for the day. I can't. If it's there, I will eat it all. It's like a coke addict saying I'll just have a little snifter to pick me up. It doesn't happen. The taste of sugar triggers a reaction, I can actually feel it, like a dopamine hit, and the only way to stop is to not have it. - 8/9/2015 2:31:32 AM
  • Actually, a lot of new studies coming out say that it's easier to control type 2 diabetes and your blood sugar level, AND lose weight, if you eat two hearty meals a day. It's better than snacking throughout the day :). Check out this article on it:

    http://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/articl
    e-2629883/Two-hearty-meals-day-better-
    6-snacks-Eating-big-breakfast-lunch-he
    lps-control-weight-blood-sugar-levels.html - 6/2/2015 9:08:32 AM
  • KAYTEETOO
    I had a problem with binge eating for over 25 years. The only thing that has worked for me is the method described in Kathryn Hansen' s book Brain Over Binge. Basically to realise that although a primitive part.of your brain is urging you to binge, the highest human part of your brain controls your actions and so you do not have to binge. 5 months binge-free and counting.... - 5/12/2015 2:05:52 PM
  • In the past, I have found that NONE of the above suggestions have ever worked. They delay the binge a few hours!

    I tend to be deliberate in my binge eating. I actually DECIDE that I am going to the store to buy a particular item (usually a box of sugary cakes or candy) and eat the entire box.
    I decide that I don't care and that I want the item so I WILL have it. period. ....Immediately after, I feel sick and horrible for what I've done.

    What DOES work for me is when I get it in my head to binge, I grab a piece of minty gum...
    ~foods taste horrible after eating a mint or peppermint gum! By the time the mint has worn off I've managed to get it all under control. - 4/17/2015 10:33:51 PM
  • ALZOLA
    I am so grateful for sparkpeople, I am disable and it been hard to excersise more than ten minutes,so I love coach Nicole and all the advise and help I get thanks. - 4/16/2015 11:32:19 AM
  • I'm nearly 59 and I've had binge eating disorder since I was 8.

    In my experience it's a lifelong disorder and there is no "cure" but I have learnt to have more control over my cravings and eat more sensibly since I had a gastric bypass at the beginning of 2009. It does help that there are certain very unpleasant side effects from the procedure if you eat the wrong thing or do the wrong thing.

    I have a real problem with leaving open packets or leaving food on my plate, maybe it's an OCD thing, so while I do have trigger foods around the house I buy them in individual packs and don't have too many packs around. As the article suggests I do find the cravings easier to control when I allow myself small portions of these foods on a regular basis. I don't 'diet' I have an eating plan.

    It's very hard not to feel guilty when the 'binge eating monster' gets out of control but I treat it as something seperate from myself and so I can draw a line under the bingeing incident and immediately get back to my planned eating. I do not restrict myself or try to work the binge into my calorie intake for the day/week as I find this more likely to trigger another binge.

    That's just some of the ideas that have helped me to have more control and generally eat better. - 1/18/2015 6:28:17 AM

Comment Pages (5 total)
[1]

Leave a comment


  Log in to leave a comment.